The Centre for Fortean Zoology was founded in the UK in 1992 - nearly 20 years ago. Over the past two decades it has expanded to become a truly global organisation. We opened our American office in 2001, our Australian office in 2009, and now - in our 19th year - we are proud to welcome CFZ Canada to the CFZ global family.

Wednesday, 30 January 2013

Long Before the Ikea Monkey

Some of you have been following the saga of the pet monkey found wandering in a Toronto Ikea store in December 2012.  If you aren't aware, the story can be found here.  The  rhesus macaque is most definitely a live, recognizable primate.  But in 2009, a person saw what he believed to be a monkey in Ajax, Ontario.

Initially, I approached this as a cryptozoology investigation, as there was no precedent for the ghost of a monkey.  A section of the initial report is as follows:

 On a daily basis and sometimes twice a day, I take my Labrador Retriever for a walk along the lakefront of the old cottage town of Pickering Beach; this has been a routine of mine for several years now. On this average day I was just strolling about the Lakefront 
 ... Rex my dog took a large and sudden leap and I veered to my right towards a large house and he started to bark quite out of the ordinary. I pulled Rex back and as I did I saw, as I have before, this strange long hairy tail (something like that of a cats but much longer) wrapped about the mid section of a tree on this property, then it just vanished. I continued to walk while Rex was barking away and looked again to the other side of the tree and there I saw the image of a monkey, a small round-headed little thing peering from the opposite side of the tree; this throwing a sheer shiver down my spine. It was seemingly chattering away directly at me but I couldn’t make out the exact sound other than a faint 'chtch, chtch, chtch' noise. This monkey sprang from the tree and ran across in front of Rex and I across the street towards the park into the ditch and back again to the property where it vanished towards the back of the house. This took a few short seconds, swift and agile as one would expect a monkey to be, the entire time this faint image looking right at us in a rather playful way however with it's teeth showing making it quite scary! As soon as I would see this monkey It would be gone, it vanishing to the back of this grey house and Rex calming down almost immediately. ... I would say that that without a doubt this is nothing that is real, no actual living animal as it's a faint image but enough that I can state for certain what it looks like and can identify it as a monkey. ... an experience I have had 6 times before

The witness also reported speaking with others, including his wife, who had seen this in the same area many time previously.

All local zoos were contacted and none were missing any monkeys, recently or for at least two years.  The municipal area restricts ownership of monkeys, but since not everyone is law abiding, a search was done to see if they are in fact available for purchase.  One seller was located in Sudbury.  Primates are generally considered inappropriate as pets and it would be extremely unlikely that someone in the area had one that got loose.   Additionally, the only likely monkey who could survive unsheltered in this climate would be the Snow Monkey, or Japanese Macaque.  

The only North American free range Snow Monkeys known are located in Texas. No monkeys have been reported missing among any local shelters or police departments.  After further discussion with the witness, I began investigating this as an actual apparition of an animal.

A cursory visit to the site revealed it to be nearly beachfront.  There is a large park between the actual beach of Lake Ontario and the homes in the area.
(aerial photo of Pickering Beach—1984)
There are two paved roadways between homes and water.  When I visited, the area was generally snow covered with many footprints—human, dog, cat, and what appeared to be squirrel.  Nothing that looked like monkey tracks was apparent.

Pickering Beach was at one time a cottage area for upscale Toronto families.  Established by lawyer James Tuckett in the 1920’s, it was a vacation site for the Corbets, Eatons, and Loblaws, among other prominent families.  The cottages have largely been replaced by large homes and the area is now part of the Town of Ajax.  Prior to becoming the beach resort, the area was cow pasture with a few trees and a small apple orchard.

During witness visits to the park, he located a memorial bench placed by the Corbet family.  At the witness suggestion, I contacted Christian Corbet, renowned artist, with questions regarding his experience at Pickering Beach and his relationship that led to placing the bench.  The Corbet family built the first permanent home at Pickering Beach in 1950 (demolished 2005).  Mr. Corbet was extremely helpful.  He was born in the area and raised by his grandparents.  And his Grandmother  Alice Charlotte (Gould ) Corbet had a monkey.

(Alf Gould and Chico)
Mr. Corbet’s Great Grandmother Priscilla Foden Gould (1891-1977) was probably psychic and could see auras. She also was a believer in reincarnation.  Not all of the family was supportive of this thinking, but to have the element in the family heritage may be relevant.   The monkey Chico was purchased at from the ASPCA in December 1933 as a companion animal to a cat.  Alice Gould wanted this cat, and Chico was offered as a bonus and became a gift for Alice’s twin brother Alfred Ernest Gould (1924-2001).  Alice continued to care for the monkey, named Chico, after her  brother Alf went off with the RAF in World War II. 

Alice and her brother Alfred were twins born to Priscilla and Fredrick James Gould in March 1924.  Alice died in 2004.

Alice Corbett was a huge part of the local school, Pickering Beach .  As a school board trustee, she fought for equal rights for women and equality among religions, creeds and races.   Alice Corbet is regarded as the first fully elected woman school board trustee on Ontario and most probably in all of Canada.  She served until 1965.

(Alice Gould Corbet and Chico)
Chico was a wonderful pet until about 1943.  He was often dressed in clothing and would play poker and chatter pleasantly.  After he bit Alice’s hand, his temperament changed and he became rather mean and unpleasant.  He required regular caging and was on a chain when outside.  He also had a fondness for eating onions.  Chico regularly escaped and would run across the road toward the local school.

Chico died January 1971 and is buried near Pickering Beach.  Current Pickering Beach area construction has not disturbed the gravesite and it is believed that Chico is still resting undisturbed.  Grandfather Corbet  (Alfred John Corbet. II 1922-1989) built a true coffin and Chico rests with a pillow and a blanket after a family funeral.

Most investigators and enthusiasts believe in the DPH (Dead Person Hypothesis, a phrase coined by Dr. Eric Ouelett, PhD) which is the idea that apparitions, poltergeists, etc.  are the result of human beings who have died and whose “spirit” or “energy” remains.  Could this be true for animals as well?  If so, is it all animals or just those closely related to humans, like this monkey would be?  If investigated like general ghost reports (i.e., using DPH) then the actions, location, and history would support the idea of a “ghost monkey”;   Chico being an extraordinary animal with close paranormal ties and a turbulent life who returns to his favourite places.

If we accept that humans can be ghosts, does this sighting make a case for all primates?  How about for all animals?  Would Sasquatch be a ghost?

Many thanks go to the original witness and to Mr. Christian Corbet for the wonderful support for this investigation.  If you have seen Chico and would like to send your report please contact me at

“What you cannot see, you cannot say does not exist”  --Christian Cordell Corbett

Telephone conversation with Mr Christian Corbett,  January 2010 with several follow-up emails.
Telephone Contact with Bowmanville Zoo, Toronto Zoo, Bergeron’s Animals, the Toronto Humane Society,  Humane Society of Durham Region, RCMP, Durham Regional Police Service,  February 2010 (Pickering Ajax Digital Archive)

Wednesday, 23 January 2013

Renwer, MB 1960

Archie Motkaluk is a Canadian born to Ukrainian parents, although much of their immigration paperwork says “Austria Galicia”.  His father immigrated in 1903 and was already married.  Archie is one of 11 children in this family.  The family farmed near Renwer, Manitoba, which is about 20 miles from the nearest “larger” town, Swan River.  Swan River had about 3000 people in 1960.

Archie’s father had arthritis and found farming quite difficult.  All of the children were expected to help.  After his high school graduation, Archie spent two years mining in Thompson, Manitoba.  Thompson is about center in Manitoba, while Renwer/Swan River is near the Saskatchewan line and further south—at about the same Latitude as Saskatoon, Saskatchewan.  The farms were laid out east to west about a mile wide for each property.  The property then extended several miles.  Archie recalls that there were about 8 farms, and all backed onto the “Crown Land” Boreal Forest.  This forest separates the tundra of the north from the deciduous forests of the south.  It is about 1000 km wide and stretches from the westernmost part of Newfoundland through to the Yukon/Alaskan border.  It is a vast amount of Canada’s land mass, yet only houses 14% of the population.  The northern part of the Boreal Forest is quite cold and has fewer trees, the size of which gets smaller the further north you go until reaching the tundra.

The area of the Boreal Forest where Renwer is located is rich in natural resources, and heavily forested.  Species populations currently found there probably began about 5000 years ago, well after the retreat of the Wisconsin Ice Sheet.  Regions are largely uniformly grown; mass amounts of flora damaged in cyclical disasters like fire or insect manifestation.  These naturally occurring events would wipe out widespread areas, then the areas would all regenerate at about the same time.  Prior to modern man settling there, the cycles were 75 to 100 years, and in some areas that is still the case.  Deforestation due to humans has been minimal across Canada in these regions, although it does occur.  Currently, the Canadian Boreal Forest is still 91% of what it was prior to European encroachment.

Trees native to the boreal include Black Spruce, White Spruce, Balsam Fir, Larch (Tamarack), Lodgepole Pine, Jack Pine, Trembling and Large-Toothed Aspen, Cottonwood and White Birch, and Balsam Poplar.  
Fauna in the area include shrubs, mosses, and lichens. Willow, alder, blueberry, red-osier dogwood, and honeysuckle, produce bright-coloured or conspicuous berries that attract fruit-eating birds and provide food for mammals.

The Canadian Boreal Forest is populated with thousands of living creatures.  It is a breeding ground for over 12 million water fowl and millions of land birds as diverse as vultures, hawks, grouse, doves, cuckoos, owls, nighthawks, swifts, hummingbirds, kingfishers, woodpeckers and passerines.  There are 1.5 million lakes in Canada’s Boreal Forest and large boreal lakes have cold water species of fish like trout and whitefish, while in warmer waters, species include northern pike, walleye and smallmouth bass.  There are about 130 different species of fish in the area.  This forest shelters more than 85 species of mammals, including wood bison, elk, moose, woodland caribou, grizzly and black bears, and wolves as well as smaller species, such as beavers, snowshoe hares, Canada lynx, red squirrels, lemmings, and voles.  The snowshoe hare is the most ecologically important as it is food source for many of the local predators (both mammals and birds) and feeds on the forest’s various plants and shrubs.  It is estimated that 32,000 insect species are present, although about one third of these species have yet to be described. Several are particularly well adapted to their habitat-- black fire beetles have infrared sensing organs on their bodies that allow them to track the heat of forest fires as they search for freshly burned trees on which to lay their eggs; the white-spotted sawyer beetle use their long antennae to sense chemicals in smoke and charcoal to achieve the same goal. These two beetle species are an important part of the diet of several bird species commonly found in burned forests.  Aside from the farmers at the very south edge of the forest, the area is home to about 80% of Aboriginal peoples in Canada.

At this point, not much damage has occurred due to issues like population, pollution, flooding for hydro power, mining and drilling, or climate change.  These things do happen, but it is usually much localized and the government, both national and provincial, are starting to take steps toward regulation and preservation.  One of the most intensive studies is that of the permafrost thaw and how that will affect the peat and wetlands in the area.  Additionally, there is recurring drought in some areas of the forest bed, causing issues for plant life there.  There are 5.7 million square kilometers of Canadian Boreal Forest and roughly 6% of this is permanently protected.  Another 4% is currently temporarily protected.  There are 90 species listed as endangered (465 for all of Canada).

Aside from a small Provincial Park east of the Renwer area, the Boreal Forest of concern in this report is not protected lands.  It is currently considered part of “Agro Manitoba”, the most densely populated part of Manitoba.  Some measures are already in place, but the government is attempting to assist landowners with ways of preserving privately owned property for conservation into perpetuity. 

The Renwer area is home to several animal species, but the only remotely upright animal of significant size is the American Black Bear.

Although they do have a period of dormancy during the winter, they do not fully hibernate.  It would thus be possible for Mr. Motkaluk to have seen one on December 29, 1960 in the Boreal Forest at the back of his father’s farm tract.  Realistically, since he had lived on the property for 20 years—all of his life—he would have known well what a black bear looks like.  His certainty that what he saw was not a bear cannot be doubted.

What did Archie Motkaluk see that winter day?  He saw an upright being, immediately thought to be human, walking at the edge of the woods.  He was not under the influence of any alcohol or medication.  He was a healthy 20 year old man, in the area to cut wood for the family farm.

Archie Motkaluk was one of 11 children who worked this family farm.  He knew his way around animals, both domestic and wild.  From about age 12 he was included in hunting parties to bring back game for food for the family.  He knew how to use a gun, and in fact had one with him that day.  He brought it because he knew he would be in the presence of animals, and poor farmers of the 1960’s would not pass up an opportunity to bring back meat if the occasion arose.  He did not necessarily feel he needed protection; he simply was prepared for hunting if he saw anything worth bringing home.  He had traveled the approximately 3 miles from the farmhouse with a team of horses and a small sleigh for carrying the firewood back.  He tethered his horses to a tree that appeared to be dying, and he took his axe to the tree line.  The area where the family gathered their wood was a relatively large clearing, about 400 square yards, which Mr. Motkaluk identifies as “about the size of four city blocks”.  He had been there hundreds of times in his 20 years.  He left the farmhouse at about 10am that day.  It was not snowing, as the area had considerably less snow than normal that year.  In fact, there were only about 4 or 5 inches of snow on the ground.  He also recalls that it was not particularly cold, but in Manitoba that could still mean well below zero.  Records indicate that a record high for the area was 10C on December 1, 1960 in Brandon, Manitoba, and the average high for the Renwer area at the end of December is about -10C.  Average snowfall for the month of December there is 26cm and no records were set at any date near the time of Mr. Motkaluk’s event.  Nearby Swan River historical weather data shows the high was -2C and the low was -14 with no new snow for the previous four days.

At the far end of the clearing, Mr. Motkaluk saw what he believed to be a man.  It stood on two feet, completely upright, and he assumed it was one of the local farmers hunting for meat for the family.  The man was walking slowly along the edge of the trees, stopping occasionally to pick and eat what Mr. Motkaluk believes was “cranberries and frozen chokecherries”.  Boreal Manitoba  native fruit species include the beaked hazelnut, blueberry, bog cranberry, buffalo berry, bunchberry, choke cherry, cloudberry, currant, elderberry, gooseberry, wild grape, hawthorn, high-bush cranberry, lingonberry, mountain ash, pin cherry, prickly pear cactus, wild raspberry, wild rose, Saskatoon, and wild strawberry.  It is entirely possible that the creature was foraging for fruit left on the bushes and vines.  Mr. Motkaluk continued to watch the “man” as he was chopping his wood.  After about an hour, the “man was approximately 100 yards away.  It was at that point Mr. Motkaluk noticed something was wrong.

By the time the creature was 50 yards away, Mr. Motkaluk believed he was seeing a Sasquatch.  After graduating high school, he had worked for two years in the mines near Thompson, Manitoba.  Many of the workers there told stories about the creature, and this sparked enough interest for Mr. Motkaluk to seek out magazine and newspaper articles on the subject.  There weren’t many available at the time, but he says he would read anything he found on the subject.  Through the stories and the articles, he believed that Sasquatch would only be found in British Columbia.  With a mere 50 yards between them, Mr. Motkaluk stopped chopping wood and watched.  The creature came to within 8 to 10 feet of where he was standing.  Mr. Motkaluk is 6’4” tall and at that time weighed about 220 pounds.  He describes the sasquatch as slightly shorter and about 325 pounds; and female.  He could not see genitalia, but breasts were clearly evident.  The two stared at each other and the creature made snarling, hissing, groaning, and grunting sounds, as well as grinding its teeth.  This went on for what seemed like 6 or 7 minutes.  Then the animal stopped making noise and they continued to stare at each other for an additional 4 or 5 minutes.  Mr. Motkaluk says he felt frozen to the spot, unable to move.  Eventually, he was able to take a step back.  When he did so, the Sasquatch also took a single step back.  They continued this pattern, with each taking two or three steps backward until they were about 20 yards apart.  The Sasquatch turned and again began foraging for food, and Mr. Motkaluk returned to his sleigh.

Once seated on the sleigh, he began to relax and ate his lunch.  He then took his axe—and this time his rifle—and went back to chop wood.  The Sasquatch was still there, watching him.

Because of the close proximity, Mr. Motkaluk was able to get a quite detailed description.  He says the Sasquatch was covered in very fine hair, dark brown in color.  The hair was no longer than one inch and was shiny, much like a domestic house cat. It had a light brown face without hair, although the hair did continue onto its neck.  Only the back of its ears had fur.  He describes the visage as that of a “middle aged aboriginal with a stern face”.  Its teeth were wider than normal human teeth, he estimated about 5/8 of and inch wide.  There were no distinct canines (or fangs as he described them) leading Mr. Motkaluk to believe the Sasquatch was strictly a vegetarian.  The soles of its feet and the palms of its hands were grey, and the tops of each had the same fine hair.  Mr. Motkaluk said it “looked very human” and nothing at all like a monkey or other primate.  The arms were proportional to the body in the same way as a human.  The fingers were a bit fat, but not disproportional to the overall size of the animal.   He likened it to photos he has seen of Neanderthal Man.  There was no distinct smell of any kind.  The animal appeared very clean and well groomed.  Its face was distinctly human.  The nose was slightly larger than average, but definitely not flat like a primate.  There were eyebrows of a darker color than the face, as well as very human looking eyes.  He believes they were brown.  Ears were clearly visible and looked human.  He jokingly said what he saw was basically a 325 pound hairy woman.

Mr. Motkaluk said that many enthusiasts describe Sasquatch as having no neck but that is definitely not the case.  What he saw had at least a 3 inch tall neck and was able to look from side to side without turning its body.  He did say that he does not believe Sasquatch is capable of running, at least not fast.  He describes the gait as a side to side wobble, again much like a large and heavy human woman or perhaps a child who is just learning to walk.  He also said that from time to time the Sasquatch would have difficulty picking up the small berries from the ground or the bushes.

The Sasquatch stayed in the area with him for a total of about 4 hours.  Mr. Motkaluk finished his wood chopping and loaded his sleigh and returned home.  He is certain the Sasquatch was still standing there watching him when he left.

Archie Motkaluk returned to his family farm at about 4pm.  His father reminded him to groom and stable the horses, and after that Archie went into the house.  His mother was immediately concerned and asked what was wrong, saying he “looked white as a ghost”.  Archie assured her there was nothing wrong and retired to his room where he wrote the whole incident down.  He had no “regular” paper so he wrote it on brown paper bags.  When he returned to his mother, she would not let up and urged him to tell her what was wrong.  He told her of the sighting and she had him draw what he saw.  His mom was an avid reader and knew of Sasquatch and never tried to tell him he was mistaken.  He took his writings and drawings and put them in an envelope, where they stayed untouched in his basement in Winnipeg for nearly 50 years.

Mr. Motkaluk was raised Ukrainian Orthodox and still considers himself of that faith.  He has had no other events in his life that he would consider paranormal.  He has had recurring nightmares of the encounter, and for the first 10 years after the sighting he sought medical help to get to sleep.  Otherwise, he doesn’t think the encounter has changed anything.

He was watching Outdoor Life Network (OLN) and was interested in a show about Bigfoot/Sasquatch.  There was an “expert” from the Pacific Northwest who said that the phenomena were not real but rather a product of overactive imaginations.  Mr. Motkaluk was outraged.  He decided that his story needed to be told; until that time he had told nobody except his mother because when he would think about it he would become upset.  His wife of almost half a century did not even know.  He talked to her, and then he rewrote his notes into an article and attempted to get it printed in the Winnipeg Free Press.  Because it was 11 pages long, they refused to run it so he took it to the Winnipeg Sun.  They questioned him for two hours about what he had seen and finally decided he wasn’t lying.  They promised to run his article, but in fact ran only a small human interest piece based on the interview.  Since then he has been on the radio once, and was promised to be brought back for a call in show.  That never materialized because the station felt it had become “old news”.  Mr. Motkaluk is clearly frustrated with media and is not seeking any fame or recognition with his sighting experience.  He has not attempted to “sell” his “story” in any fashion.  He said he had been contacted by researchers from all over North America, about 200 people in his estimation.
I spoke with Mr. Motkaluk for well over an hour on a Friday evening via telephone.  I found him to be very like-able  of at least average intelligence, and very proud of his “farm boy” heritage.  I saw no signs of mental illness, including Alzheimer’s, nor do I believe he manufactured his sighting.  I encouraged him to protect his original notes and drawings and to carefully select someone to receive them when he is no longer able to keep them.  Although his exposure to discussion of Sasquatch prior to his sighting is somewhat problematic, what he describes is not typical media information.

Mr. Motkaluk’s testimony is compelling in its detail and the supporting possibilities—dense forestation, minimal human population, abundance of vegetation for subsistence—makes a good case for the acceptance that the Sasquatch phenomenon is real.  I’m convinced that it is definitely real for him, and likely for his family members who now know the story.

Journal of Ecology. 1978. 66(1): 199-212
Conservation Biology. 2003. 17(5): 1435-1439

Thursday, 10 January 2013

Free Willys

Killer whales are no strangers to Canadian waters. In fact, orcas are living in every ocean on earth.  The highest densities of killer whales are in the northeast Atlantic around the Norwegian coast, in the north Pacific along the Aleutian Islands, the Gulf of Alaska and in the Southern Ocean off much of the coast of Antarctica. They are also common in the eastern Pacific along the coasts of British Columbia, Washington and Oregon, in the North Atlantic Ocean around Iceland and the Faroe Islands.  It isn't unheard of to spot some in Baffin Bay.  At this time of year, however, it is unusual for them to be gathered near Inukjuak, Quebec in Hudson Bay.  They often visit arctic water in more temperate weather, but rarely come near an ice pack.  Recently a group of up to 18 of them were trapped under the ice in this location.  Their presence in this spot is what is cryptic.

While there is  rapid Arctic sea ice decline in the Hudson Strait, it is still unlikely that killer whales would come into the bay in the winter.  Average December and January temperature onshore is -15C, with an average low nearly -30C.  The latest ice charts for the area show not only normal ice present, but significantly lower temperatures just east of the Hudson Straight, and the whales would have had to have passed through there to get to their current location. While ice coverage is still below normal historically, there is about twice as much ice there this year as there was just two years ago.

Occasionally, killer whales swim into freshwater rivers.  Beluga whales, native to the area, winter in the open waters of the Hudson Straight and in the spring return to the larger rivers nearby for calving.  Belugas are typically gone from the Bay itself by the time the ice gets just a couple of inches thick.  The freshwater river that flows into the bay at this area is full of rapids, and not nearly deep enough to house killer whales, even for a short time.  As the ice builds along the shore and into the river, the tide action pushes it up creating a very ragged terrain of solid ice.  For most of the winter, this ice is very thick which would make it difficult for the air-breathing orcas to surface.  In the past few days, the wind and tides have been slowly closing the pickup truck sized hole the whales were using for breathing.

Winds shifted overnight, however, and today the whales appear to have escaped to open water.  Will they come back?

Inujjuamiut Foraging Strategies: Evolutionary Ecology of Arctic Hunting Economy By Eric Alden Smith